Adam Westbrook // ideas on digital storytelling and publishing

The ultimate budget film making kit

Posted in Journalism by Adam Westbrook on February 23, 2009

Last year I wrote a post about my ideas for the future of TV news. It’s been one of the most read articles on my blog and solicited a lot of nice comments.

One comment, by blogger Thoroughly Good, made a (thoroughly good) point:

“Grab a camera or a microphone and go make the stuff *you* want to make. Stick it on the web.  If no-one consumes it then satisfy yourself with the thought you’ve satisfied yourself making something which satisfies you not the audience .. That’s the most important thing of all,” he said.

“So, when exactly can we see something?”

Good question. The prize is out there for those who go for it. Another media blogger, Dave Lee reckons 2009 will be the year Video Journalism ‘arrives’.

And I hope to be in the welcome party when it does; but the problem is cost. As great as it is to “grab a camera and a microphone”, it’s not cheap.

Sure, there’s lots of talk about how cameras are a fraction of the cost they used to be ‘and no-longer prohibitively expensive’. But if you want a decent filmmaker hallmark – say the Sony Z1 – you’re talking £2,000 ($3-4,000).

Here’s a good example: in Andy Glynne’s (excellent) book “Documentaries…and how to make them” he details the different set up costs for filmmakers. His “basic kit” is this:

  • Camera: Sony HDR-Z1E –> £3,000 + VAT
  • Batteries x 2: £99 each
  • Microphone: Sennheiser ME66 + shotgun –> £400
  • Headphones: Sennheiser HD201 –> £15
  • Mic grip: –> £77
  • Camera bag: Portabrace –> £180
  • Tripod: Manfretto MN755 –> £148
  • XLR cables, raincover etc: –> £80

TOTAL: ~£4,000

And that’s before you get to editing. The upper range kit he suggests, reaches £7,000 and beyond.

For me – and many other young independents – that IS prohibitively expensive.

But I haven’t let that deter me. Over the last five months I have been compiling my own VJ kit, for a fraction of the cost. In fact, I believe I have managed it for just over £500.

I’ve decided to publish how I did it- maybe it’ll inspire some other budget filmmakers to give it a go.

The ultimate budget film making kit

I’ve learned there are two secrets to getting a kit together on the cheap:

  1. What you don’t spend in money, you must spend in time – that’s time looking around, not rushing into deals, properly exploring the options.
  2. Know exactly what you need each piece of kit to do: a £600 HD cam is no good, if it doesn’t have anywhere to plug in an external microphone, for example.

The camera

For a professional/semi-professional film maker a camera MUST have the following elements: manual focus, manual white balance, external mic option, hot shoe for attaching a mic, manual sound control. And ideally: 3CCD (for broadcast), manuel iris/shutter control and 16:9 widescreen, although these are by no means compulsory.

That immediately wipes out a lot of the consumer models, regardless of how light, cheap or flashy they are.

The budget filmmaker must be content with 2nd hand models as well. Often on ebay these are auctioned at cheaper rates. Ebay also has a healthy selection of 2nd hand Canon XM1s, XM2s and even XL2s – but these will eventually sell for at least £700.

Some of the manuel settings on the NVDX100

Some of the manuel settings on the NVDX100

In my searches I discovered two reliable options that remained cheap: the Canon MVX250i and the Panasonic NVDX100. I was outbid in the former at the last second, but I snapped up the latter for a David Dickensian £189. It retailed at £2,000 when it first went on the market so a good buy by my reckoning.

It runs on MiniDV and being old is a tadge cumbersum, but it has 3CCD and more manual options than you care to mention. It came with three batteries, and a camera bag.

The microphone

A brief search round the internet brought me to Pro Audio Systems, a UK company specialising in professional audio. There I picked up a mic, with hot shoe attachment for £42. It has it’s own battery and a wind cover.

The tripod

Some VJ’s argue a tripod is an option rather than a rule, especially if you want to really push the envelope with creative filming. I would still argue it’s necessary for close ups, and long interviews. But you don’t really need it to perform amazing pans or tilts, so don’t overspend on a flashy Manfretto/Vinten. I picked one up for £15.99 on Ebay. It has a quick-release head to get the camera off quick which is good, and it’s very light.

The edit machine

Here I have had to make one of the biggest compromises. A VJ doesn’t look like a VJ unless they’ve got a laptop for portable editing. And ideally a Macbook. But that’s way out of my league, and instead I’ve opted for the best power v cost ratio.

And that means a desktop. Old school, I know. But editing won’t work without the following key elements: 160GB harddrive (minimum), 2GB of ram, 3ghz processer, and firewire port. We’re talking near the £1,000 mark for that in Apple form, but with a desktop that is within reach of £200 on Ebay.

After literally months of patient stalking in the Ebay jungle, I snapped up a surplus order from Ireland, for a meagre £150. With 250GB of diskspace, a 2.8ghz processor and 2GB of RAM it’s a bargain – and worth the wait.

The other crucial thing for editing is a good monitor. I picked up a 24” flatscreen from Play.com for £120 with free delivery.

The editing software adobe-screenshot

And of course without a Macbook, you are without Final Cut Pro, the staple of video editors everywhere. But even if I had been given a Macbook, FCP is prohibitively expensive. But there are other options: AVID are still a professional catchall, and Adobe’s Creative Suite are breaking new ground in the pro-sumer market.

In the end it was Adobe which caught my attention. Their software Adobe Premiere (currently on edition CS4) is well received. But best of all for the budget filmmaker, they produce a budget version – Adobe Premiere Elements (currently on version 7) , which retails close to £70.

There are some good bargains on ebay, but surprisingly it was Amazon who won this round – flogging it for £52 including free delivery. Cha-ching!

But what do you lose with the Elements version? Well, this is where knowing what requirements you need comes in. I’m a trained bi-media journalist, and after hours on Final Cut Pro, and in the classroom learning the craft of writing to pictures, I think a VJ really only needs a few basic requirements from their editor: the ability to separate audio from video, and a large number of audio/video tracks on which to multitrack. Without those, no matter how great the special effects or “upload straight to Youtube” functions, you can’t perform basic edits.

I spent a long time researching Adobe Premiere Elements, and eventually got a confirmation it is capable of those key functions. And having messed around with it on my own too, I can confirm it’s very similar to Apple’s Final Cut Pro in terms of usability. Click here to check out what it can do for yourself.

Straight to checkout…

  • Camera: Panasonic NVDX100 :: Ebay :: £189.00
  • Microphone: Audio Technica ATR25 :: Pro Audio Systems :: £42.00
  • Tripod: Camlink TP-2100 :: Ebay :: 15.99
  • Edit hardware:  Dell Optiplex 745 :: Ebay :: 150.00
  • Edit monitor: Acer 24” flatscreen :: Play.com :: £120.00
  • Edit software: Adobe Premiere Elements 7 :: Amazon :: £52.10

TOTAL:£569.09

So that’s the full kit – for just a smidgen over £500. I hope any other young journalists/filmmakers who feel it’s all out of their range will read this and see it is possible.

And if you’ve got great ideas and some creativity, you can make great content with the most basic of items.

“So, when exactly can we see something?”

Hopefully, very soon.

About these ads

41 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Alex Murray said, on February 23, 2009 at 11:20 am

    Great call on the Panasonic and Canon’s. Really the Z1 is massively over-specced for a lot of stuff so when people say “this is the standard” what they seem to mean is “this is the received industry wisdom”. I”ve always found it an uncomfortable camera to operate handheld and the ergonomics are annoying. Even the Canon XL1 that I learnt on had the controls in better places.

    I’ve had this recommended as a small tapeless handheld for shooting VJ type stuff at the 300 quid mark: http://www.canon.co.uk/For_Home/Product_Finder/Camcorders/flash_memory/FS100/index.asp

    Lacks a few features that would be good to have but, with a bit of planning, I would argue that you can probably get decent results with it. Tapeless is the future and with a few models now on the market prices should start dropping off and second-hand should start to appear. Worht keeping an eye out for I reckon.

  2. [...] Originally posted here:  The ultimate budget film making kit « Adam Westbrook [...]

  3. Ali Plumb said, on February 23, 2009 at 12:19 pm

    You need a Flip Cam – http://tinyurl.com/amqv9q

    It’s very, very neat, and the sound quality is surprisingly good.

  4. adamwestbrook said, on February 23, 2009 at 4:10 pm

    @Ali, ah but where’s its manual functions? What if you need to adjust the white balance, or perform a manual focus?

    @Alex Murray nice choice on that Canon. Is there a shoe to attach an external mic?

    • Alex Murray said, on August 19, 2009 at 9:54 am

      @Adam, yes I think the Canon does have a hotshoe to attach an external mic.

  5. Ed Moore said, on February 23, 2009 at 4:53 pm

    Nice kit. I ended up with the Kodak Zi6 which was perfect for the stuff I’ve been doing at http://www.thedopdiaries.com – people can’t believe it’s a camera worth £80!

  6. adamwestbrook said, on February 23, 2009 at 5:06 pm

    £80 very nice! In fact both the Kodak and the Flip make great cheap backup cameras, or video diary types ones. I guess the perfect VJ kit contains more than one camera.

  7. Ali Plumb said, on February 23, 2009 at 7:58 pm

    You got me there Adam – but they’re so easy, so cheap, so… ‘neat’.

  8. Deborah Potter said, on February 25, 2009 at 3:57 am

    Appreciate your sharing not just the list of gear but why you chose it and how you found it for less. I’ve been using Premiere Elements for years and also find it does everything I need. I’d love to see someone on this (US) side of the pond replicate your shopping prowess. Hope you’ll post some video soon so we can see the results.

  9. [...] too much? Consider the Adam Westbrook approach. Decide what you really need, then take your time looking for the lowest possible prices [...]

  10. cyndygreen said, on March 5, 2009 at 2:05 pm

    Hmmm…I did a similar price-check a while back for non-pros or newspapers who want to get their toes wet without blowing the budget. A Canon ZR60 for around $80 (ebay), old mike I found in a drawer from a tape deck, $15 Velbon tripod from ebay. Already had a Mac w/iMovie or could use Final Cut Express (still pretty expensive at $300). But yours is definitely more pro-looking. Great to see the budget-minded are still able to stay in the game.
    It’s outdated, but here’s the line:
    http://cyndygreen.wordpress.com/2006/12/15/low-end-gear-can-do-the-job/

  11. Adam Westbrook said, on March 9, 2009 at 9:02 am

    [...] Posts The ultimate budget film making kitGay in Ghana?Journalism’s “fame academy” gets bloggingDiscrimination in the media: it’s not race – [...]

  12. [...] Regiment in Iraq. On assignment for my employer – a radio station – I was also armed with a DV Camera and digital camera, hoping, desperately to come back with high quality video, audio and [...]

  13. [...] technical hitches. I was very positive about my budget film making kit earlier this year, but remember, pay peanuts and you get monkeys. Adobe Premiere Elements is great value for money, [...]

  14. Rupert said, on April 11, 2009 at 8:41 am

    Great post – refreshing to hear someone being realistic about the cost of kit for once, and great ideas.
    Sony Vegas is also great for editing. I think the entry-level version is less than Premiere Elements, and it does everything you need – and it’s very good at handling different types of video files from tapeless cameras without having to import or transcode them.

  15. [...] The ultimate budget film making kit :: a guide to how I kitted myself out for video journalism on a £500 budget [...]

  16. Paul Treacy said, on April 27, 2009 at 3:27 pm

    Great stuff. I will follow your lead and sort out a basic mini dv setup too. Currently I’m working with the Flip Mino and enhancing it with stills from my D200 workhorse. iMovie 08 works well for me a the moment but I do feel the need for more video tracks and will try Premier as per your suggestion.

  17. Paul Treacy said, on April 27, 2009 at 3:29 pm

    Great stuff. I will follow your lead and sort out a basic mini dv setup too. Currently I’m working with the Flip Mino and enhancing it with stills from my D200 workhorse. iMovie 08 works well for me a the moment but I do feel the need for more video tracks and will try Premier as per your suggestion.

    Here’s my G20 film at Openfilm.com, a site worth exploring;

    http://www.openfilm.com/videos/g20_demo/

    http://photohumourist.com

  18. [...] The ultimate budget film making kit [...]

  19. One Week in Iraq « Adam Westbrook said, on May 19, 2009 at 7:50 pm

    [...] on from earlier articles about kitting out on the cheap, One Week In Iraq follows the same vein, with the only cost being the domain name and hosting. [...]

  20. [...] They may start off hiring the kit, but eventually will become a one-person news operation, with their own cameras, audio recorders and editing equipment. [...]

  21. [...] Check out my article on how I put together an entire film making kit for £500 ($800). [...]

  22. [...] Check out my article on how I put together an entire film making kit for £500 ($800). [...]

  23. Sanjay S. Devkar said, on December 10, 2009 at 3:34 pm

    Making a film on Bhagwan Buddha,

    this is our first ever individual effort, looking forward to seek your support in making our budget,

    Kindly help us,
    Dhanyawaad
    Sanjay S. Devkar

  24. HP Computer Repair said, on December 14, 2009 at 7:53 pm

    If I put a link back to your blog can I post an excerpt from this? I just wanted to check first.

  25. cyndy green said, on December 15, 2009 at 3:07 am

    Hoot mon…go ahead and use my stuff…couldn’t get the email link to work, but best wishes and a joyous holiday season….Cyndy Green

  26. [...] convinced? Here’s how I kitted myself out with camera, tripod, sound gear and a full editing suite for £… ($900). And watch how the Kodak Zi8 (£150) can get professional [...]

  27. [...] Posted in Journalism by adamwestbrook on April 28, 2010 For the first time since I wrote this article in 2008, I have been able to invest in some new [...]

  28. [...] theme. The kit, if you don’t have it already, can be yours for around $1000 (see my articles here and here). Then you need the cracking content: building a portfolio of remarkable work, by offering [...]

  29. [...] editing? Lots of software is free, the kit isn’t as expensive as you might think – as Adam Westbrook will tell you – and learning the discipline of broadcast story-telling and the technical aspects of editing [...]

  30. Daily File said, on October 2, 2010 at 4:46 am

    Superior weblog, I feel it is nice when people specific their positions as vehemently as you have. Solution to present your faculty delight! Make us proud!

  31. Electric Shower · said, on November 3, 2010 at 5:26 pm

    mini dv is a good way to store video information but flash cards are getting bigger in capacity too “

  32. wpolscemamymocneseo said, on January 10, 2011 at 11:07 am

    wpolscemamymocneseo

  33. Zakłady bukmacherskie said, on January 26, 2011 at 10:50 am

    Hi. I just read your site and I have to say that i totally agreeharmonise in this point of seeing it. Please try to present your point of viev more ofttimes and I will on 100% analise it. Best Regards Zakłady bukmacherskie.

  34. Alicia said, on February 7, 2011 at 11:59 pm

    I wouldnt have ever noticed you if I never tried look and research. Superb and excellent and aim delighted I saw it. Now I know what I need to do. Thanks ever so much.

  35. Artie Brye said, on February 21, 2011 at 5:58 pm

    Does your website have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it expand over time.

  36. oświetlenie said, on March 5, 2011 at 11:53 pm

    There are some interesting points in time in this article but I don’t know if I see all of them heart to heart. There’s some validity however I’ll take hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we wish more! Added to FeedBurner as well

  37. Darell Stunkard said, on April 18, 2011 at 11:13 am

    That i quite enjoy what you may submit right here. Really informative together with reasonable. A particular concern though. I’m running Firefox utilizing Debian together with segments to your active web design sections would definitely be a bit of wonky. That i realise it’s no standard arrange. But it’s an issue that will hold in the mind. That i wish that this will probably assistance together with keep the best superior posting.

  38. veve3405 said, on May 4, 2011 at 3:56 pm

    There is noticeably a lot to identify about this. I think you made some nice points in features also.Keep working ,impressive job! sewing machine tables cabinets

  39. lace shower curtains said, on August 8, 2011 at 9:56 pm

    After I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now each time a remark is added I get 4 emails with the identical comment. Is there any approach you may take away me from that service? Thanks!

  40. Tod Litza said, on September 4, 2011 at 9:25 am

    Cool post, keep up the great work!


Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 10,224 other followers

%d bloggers like this: